The Vatican made headlines this month with its release of Dignitatis Personae (Latin for "The Dignity of the Person"), which updated Catholic teachings on bioethics and reaffirmed opposition to the cloning, killing and manipulating of human embryos.
Critics have blasted the document as proof of the church's inexplicable fixation on embryos. They ask: Why devote such energy to defending the rights of a microscopic dot?
Why throw up roadblocks to the Brave New World of biotech advances -- including the detection and destruction of genetically flawed embryos in pursuit of so-called designer babies -- to save infinitesimal entities no one will miss? What's with the embryo obsession?
As the December release of the Dignitatis Personae suggests, the answer has a lot to do with the Christmas story that the world's 2 billion Christians commemorate today. That answer is grounded in a high view of the human body that leads inexorably to a high view of the human embryo.
Both are countercultural in our modern world. Since the 17th century, when philosopher Rene Descartes issued his trademark line, "I think, therefore I am," we increasingly have accepted the idea that our minds are synonymous with our selves and that our bodies merely are the matter that our minds inhabit, with no intrinsic meaning or purposes of their own.
Following this logic, we claim the right to do what we wish with our bodies as persons who reason and exercise will. The only caveat is that we may not hurt anyone else -- anyone, that is, who counts as a person with the same qualities of rationality and autonomy.
These assumptions reflect a dualistic worldview that denigrates the body, and they are rampant today. They underlie everything from our obsession with redesigning our bodies through cosmetic surgery to our flippant attitudes about sex and our growing acceptance of euthanasia for the demented and comatose.
These ideas also shape our debates over beginning-of-life issues. Supporters of legalized abortion dismiss concerns about the killing of a fetus by arguing that "it's just a blob of tissue." Backers of embryonic stem cell research say we need not trouble ourselves over the destruction of an embryo because "it's just a clump of cells."
Reason alone can refute these claims. The human embryo, like the human fetus, is a separate, self-directing individual who looks exactly as a human person should look in her earliest stages of life, exactly as each of us looked at her age. The size, location and frailty of her body do not change the two fundamental facts we need to know to determine if she has a right to life: She is human, and she is alive.
Although reasoned arguments are sufficient to defend these nascent human lives, the Christian faith professed by more than three-quarters of Americans offers additional grounds to do so.
That faith says that God became incarnate in a human body and passed through every stage of human development, including the embryonic, to redeem human beings, body and soul. In doing so, he endowed the human body in all its developmental stages with intrinsic dignity.
Polls show that a majority of Americans still believe the biblical Christmas story: A Harris Interactive Survey released this month found that 71 percent believe that Jesus is God or the Son of God and 61 percent believe in the virgin birth.
Dignitatis Personae is a timely reminder that there are life-and-death implications to those beliefs and profound connections between what we think about our bodies and what we think happened on that starry night in Bethlehem 2,000 years ago.
Colleen Carroll Campbell is an author, television and radio host and St. Louis-based fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center.
Source: eppc.org
oldmarine
'E' 카테고리의 다른 글
| Typhoon Vincent (0) | 2012.08.04 |
|---|---|
| Researchers show that brain cells hold memories (0) | 2012.04.27 |
| Reflected Glory (0) | 2012.02.14 |
| China pledges regular patrols near disputed islands (0) | 2010.12.28 |
| NASA confirm!s `alien` life is found on Earth (0) | 2010.12.04 |